PETG First Layer on the P1S: What Actually Differs

PETG on a P1S usually fails for a different reason than PETG on an Ender, and copying Ender advice makes it worse. The machine is faster, the part cooling is stronger, and the plate is textured. Those three facts change the fix.
The plate is the first difference
The textured PEI sheet the P1S ships with is excellent for PLA and actively hostile to a badly tuned PETG first layer. On a smooth plate PETG spreads; on a textured one it has to be pushed into the grain, which needs a slightly lower nozzle and slightly more squish than PLA.
Two consequences follow:
| Setting | PLA on P1S | PETG on P1S |
|---|---|---|
| Nozzle temperature | 220 | 240–250 |
| Bed temperature | 55 | 70–80 |
| First layer speed | fast | slower than you think |
| Part cooling, first layer | on | off |
That last row is the one people miss. PETG needs to stay soft for a moment to bond to the texture. Full cooling on layer one is the single most common cause of a PETG first layer that looks ragged at the edges but fine in the middle.
The textured plate needs a release agent, not an adhesive
Counter-intuitive but consistent: on the P1S textured sheet, PETG can bond so hard that a thin part tears before it releases. A light glue stick layer is a release layer here, not a glue. If you have ever pulled a piece off and left part of it on the plate, you already know this.
Flow calibration on a fast machine
The P1S prints faster than the flow model assumes at PETG temperatures. Run the automatic flow calibration with the actual filament and the actual profile, then print a single-wall cube and measure the wall. If the wall is thin, the first layer is under-extruded and no amount of Z adjustment will fix the gaps.
What to check, in order
- Part cooling off on layer one. Confirm it in the profile, not just the preview.
- Bed at 75 °C. Below 70 the corners lift; above 80 the bottom welds.
- Flow calibration with this filament. Not inherited from a PLA profile.
- A thin glue layer as release. Especially for large flat parts.
- First layer speed down. Roughly half of what you use for PLA is a fair starting point.
When it is not the settings
If the first layer is ragged only in one region of the plate, suspect a physical problem rather than a profile: a bent plate, debris under the sheet, or a nozzle that has picked up a blob during the purge. Clean the plate, run the bed mesh again, and look at whether the pattern moves with the plate or stays with the position.
If the pattern stays in the same place every print, it is the machine. If it moves with the plate, it is the plate.
FAQ
Should I dry PETG before the first print on a P1S? Yes. PETG out of the bag is often marginal and the P1S prints hot enough that moisture shows up as fine bubbles in the first layer rather than obvious stringing.
Why is my PETG first layer rough only at the edges? Cooling. The edges cool faster than the centre, and on layer one that freezes the bond before it forms. Turn fan off for layer one before you touch Z.
Is the included textured plate good for PETG? It works, but it grips hard. Use a thin glue layer as a release agent, not to increase adhesion.
Do I need to change the Z offset for PETG on a P1S? Usually not. Flow and cooling explain most first-layer defects. Change Z last, and change it in small steps.
Why does PLA print perfectly and PETG fail on the same machine? Because they fail for opposite reasons. PLA wants cooling and a fast first layer; PETG wants heat retention and a slow one. The same profile cannot serve both.